We all tried baking cookies by ourselves, didn’t we? But, most of us easily understood how hard it is to shape or size the cookies by hand. Having perfectly sized, round cookies is somewhat of an art!
So, we all gave up at some point. However, you don’t have to give up if you understand the basics and have the basic tools to make cookies. That’s where cookie scoops come in.
Having the best cookie dough scoop at your disposal should be a no-brainer by now. You don’t need to become an expert to bake good cookies. All you need is the right recipe and the right tools. If you have these two, you will have consistent, professional-looking cookies.
However, finding good cookie scoops isn’t easy. There are many sizes and many brands available on the market. That’s why our experts spent hours looking for the finest cookie scoops and made a list with only the top five.
Keep reading to find out more about them.
#List Of The Best Cookie Dough Scoop – Our Editor’s Pick:
|1||Wilton Stainless Steel Cookie Scoop, Silver||17,049 Reviews||Check Price On Amazon|
|2||Cookie Scoop Set - Include 1 Tbsp/ 2 Tbsp/ 3Tbsp -...||774 Reviews||Check Price On Amazon|
|3||OXO Good Grips Medium Cookie Scoop||10,766 Reviews||Check Price On Amazon|
|4||Cookie Scoop Set, Ice Cream Scoop Set, Multiple...||1,984 Reviews||Check Price On Amazon|
|5||Cookie Scoop Set, Tuilful Ice Cream Scoops Set of...||1,213 Reviews||Check Price On Amazon|
Top Five Best Cookie Scoop Reviews
This section contains multiple options. But, not all of them might be suitable for your needs. So, read thoroughly and choose a cookie scoop that fits your necessities.
1. Oxo Good Grips Cookie Scoop | Medium Size
Cookies can be a great gift from the heart. They take away stress with their exceptional sweetness. However, you must agree that a gift must also be made properly. A poorly baked cookie surely won’t take away anyone’s stress.
So, when it comes to cookies, you want nice and round shapes cookies that taste good too. That’s where Oxo’s good grips come in. These scoops are here to help you with exactly that. How you may ask?
Well, Oxo good grips have soft and comfortable, spring-loaded handles. So, it’s pretty easy to scoop dough comfortably with these. Also, good grips scoop even proportions every time with their beautiful, round shapes.
However, if you compare other cookie scoops with these, you will find that while other scoops struggle with sticky dough, Oxo good grips have wiper cleans, that properly ejects dough, even sticky ones.
- Three different sizes are available
- Creates uniform cookies that bake evenly
- Very soft and easy to use
- Comfortable handle for better performance
- Some users have complained about the durability
2. Norpro Cookie Scoop | Five different Sizing
If you are familiar with baking and kitchen accessories, you surely have heard of Norpro. Norpro is a very renowned kitchen accessories brand and their name speaks for their quality. So, these cookie scoops are no different.
Norpro cookie scoops are definitely the most durable cookie scoop available right now. Their stainless-steel body design with a high polished finish makes these look beautiful and also increases their longevity a lot.
However, you are not bound to use these only for cookie doughs. Norpro scoops can be used as an ice-cream scoop, to make meatballs or fruit balls too. So, these scoops are very versatile and can be very useful in the kitchen.
In conclusion, if you don’t want any more uneven cookies, you need to get a Norpro cookie scoop to help you with getting the desired shape and size.
- A hinged sweeping mechanism for easier release
- Ideal for versatile usage in the kitchen
- Five different sizes are available
- Heavy-duty spring action
- Very durable and high-quality build
- Some users have complained about counterfeits
- Some users have received defective units
3. Met Lux Cookie Scoop | Perfect Servings
If you want perfection in every scoop, you need to pay attention to Met lux. These cookie scoops serve perfect scoops every single time! With these, you can always have equal and proportionate servings.
Comfort is a very big factor when making cookies. The hands get easily fatigued if the scoop is uncomfortable. That’s why Met lux made their scoops to be very comfortable. With their easy-to-grip handle and strong thumb scoop trigger, your hands will thank you for buying these!
However, for someone who wants to make cookies of different sizes or maybe scoop different servings of ice cream, having the perfect size scoop is very important. Met lux offers not one or two, but nine different sizes of cookie scoops! So, you can find exactly the one you need.
Anyway, when compared to other cookie scoop brands, most of them don’t offer such versatility and so many different options to choose from like Met lux.
- Easily releases dough with the perfectly engineered blade
- Durable stainless-steel design to handle large scoops
- Ideal for serving many different types of food
- Very durable and sturdy
- Easy-to-grip handle for extra comfort
- These are not NSF-certified
- Not useful for left-handed persons
4. Jenaluca Cookie Scoop Set | 3 Scoop Pack
Do you want to find the perfect gift for your mom? Well, here it is. A set of 3 different-sized scoops to make her life easier and help you eat more of your mom’s delicious cookies! That’s a win-win situation, isn’t it?
Jenaluca kept exactly that in their mind when they designed this 3-scoop gift pack. This pack includes small, medium, and large-sized scoops which are versatile for any type of kitchen usage. You can scoop anything with these without any problems.
Also, these are made with 18/8 stainless steel which is very durable and very strong. So, Jenaluca scoops are guaranteed to last longer than average scoops. The ergonomic design of these scoops also makes the scoops very comfortable and easy to use.
However, if you are still not convinced that these are the best cookie scoop for you, you can compare them with other scoops on the market as these can be returned within thirty days of purchase on amazon.
- Perfectly packaged as a beautiful gift
- Doesn’t put pressure on wrist or hands
- Heavy-duty, rust-resistant, and dishwasher-safe
- A five-star rating in amazon
- Well-made with passion
- Pricier than regular cookie scoops
5. Wilton Cookie Scoop | Most Affordable
Well, Wilton has been in this business since 1929! So, you should already understand that they are not joking around. In fact, Wilton was one of the first companies to offer baking accessories. So, you can trust the brand.
However, if you believe more in the quality and less in the brand name, Wilton got you covered anyway. Their cookie scoops are one of the bests but undoubtedly the most affordable cookie scoop that actually works.
Also, the squeeze handle makes it very easy to use. All you have to do is squeeze and there you have evenly proportioned cookie dough. It’s that easy! Also, Wilton scoops have a spring handle for easy release.
Anyway, the scoops are four tablespoons in size. So, you can expect to get cookies about 2-3/4 inches in size. Although this heavily depends on loads of other things.
However, there are very few companies offering such low pricing and even a pack of two at such low prices. You won’t even get a single scoop at this price!
- Very affordable pricing from Wilton
- Squeeze handle for easy dough release
- Stainless-steel material makes the unit very durable
- Evenly proportioned cookies every time
- These are not machine-washable and need to be hand-washed
Top 5 Cookie Dough Scoop Comparison Table
Oxo Good Grips Cookie Scoop
Norpro Cookie Scoop
Met Lux Cookie Scoop
Jenaluca Cookie Scoop Set
Wilton Cookie Scoop
Buying Guide for Cookie Scoop
Cookie scoops are highly effective and essential tools for a baker. If you are just trying to make some cookies for an occasion, a cookie scoop might help you much more than you think.
Cookie scoops are spring-loaded scoops that help you scoop and measure dough properly. Although these are named cookie scoops, they can be used for a variety of other things. These can be used anytime you need to measure your dough evenly.
Also, you can use cookie scoops as ice-cream scoops too obviously. So, cookie scoops are very versatile tools, and having one in your kitchen is essential.
However, there are some things you need to keep in mind before buying a cookie scoop. As there are many sizes and brands on the market, you need to understand exactly the one you need for your necessities.
So, if you find the sizes and brands confusing to you, read the guide below to have a thorough understanding of cookie scoops.
The most essential feature of a cookie scoop is its size. There are many different sizes of cookie scoops. However, most brands don’t essentially use the same sizing chart. Although they provide a comparative sizing with US tablespoons.
The most common size for cookie scoops is “four tablespoons”. This usually gives you medium-sized cookies depending on your dough. Although sizes range from 0.5 tablespoons to 5 tablespoons.
Cookie scoops are usually sized according to their numbers. #16 is four tablespoons, #40 is 1.5 tablespoons, which also is the very common size for cookies. Learn more about cookie scoops sizes in a baker’s guide to cookie scoops.
So, you need to decide the size of cookies you want to make. If you only want to make small-sized cookies, 1.5 tablespoon scoops would be perfect for you. However, if you want to make cookies of different sizes, you might want to buy a cookie scoop set.
Cookie scoops that don’t clean easily can make such a mess! So, you need to make sure through reviews and customer opinions that the scoop you’re buying cleans easily and is dishwasher safe. This will save you a lot of time and energy.
Some cheap cookie scoops compromise their build quality and durability. Because of this, the cookie scoop bends easily when picking up the dough. So, you need to check the durability of the product you’re buying.
Uniform Cookie Sizes
This is essentially the job of the cookie scoop, isn’t it? So, if a scoop is bad at making uniformly sized cookies, what good would they be in your kitchen?
That’s why the cookie scoop needs to make uniform cookies every time. This is very important if you want to have professional-looking and tasty cookies.
If you keep these things in mind before buying a cookie scoop, you will surely find the best one for you that will last longer and leave you with a pleasant experience of cookie baking.
Types of Cookie Scoop
Cookie scoops are one of the most essential tools for any baker, especially if you are an amateur. They make the job very easy and pretty fun to do. Anyone with very little practice can learn how to make cookies with these.
So, if you want you can have fun with your kids or family while baking yummy, tasty cookies. If you are looking forward to that, you need to have the best cookie scoop set at your home.
However, it’s easy to get confused on the internet. Because there are just too many options and sizes and so much background noise. Although if you read this, you will get a detailed understanding of what you’re getting.
There are not too many types of cookie scoops. Most brands follow the same design with minor adjustments here and there. Most scoops have some kind of squeeze handle that releases the dough from the scoop.
So, the designs of the scoops are pretty similar. However, what you need to consider is the sizing. Scoops come in many different sizes. That’s why you must understand the right scoop size for cookies.
Cookies come in small, medium, large, or extra-large sizes. So, it’s only natural that scoops too have small to extra-large sizing. Although, cookie scoop sizes are mainly measured by their numbers and most brands usually provide a comparative sizing with US tablespoons.
So, regular-sized cookies usually need a scoop of three to four tablespoon size. That’s #16 to #20 in cookie scoop size number.
There are aluminum or stainless-steel cookie scoops. However, aluminum is bad for this type of utensils and mostly counterfeit scoops are made with aluminum. So, go with stainless-steel scoops because they will give you much more durability and stability.
FAQs – Frequently Asked Questions and Answers
What size cookie scoop is best for cookies?
This obviously depends on the type of cookie you’re trying to make. Most recipes mention how much dough you need to put in tablespoons. Also, most cookie scoops are measured in tablespoons.
So, you can just check the recipe for the scoop size.
Anyway, most regular-sized cookies need a scoop of three to four tablespoons in size. Learn more about cookie scoop sizes best for cookies.
What size cookie scoop do bakeries use?
As bakeries make cookies of many different sizes, they usually use scoops of many different sizes. Although usually for large cookies, most bakeries tend to use #10 cookie scoops and for medium-sized cookies, they use #20 to #30 size scoops.
How do you scoop the perfect cookie?
This needs some practice and time, of course. To scoop the perfect cookie, first, do a test trial and bake maybe one or two cookies. By this, you can understand how much your recipe spreads. This will help you portion your dough correctly.
Also, when scooping your dough, make sure that you pack the dough properly to get a completely rounded top and a flat bottom. Learn more about how to scoop the perfect cookie.
Do I really need a cookie scoop?
There are many benefits of having a cookie scoop. Cookie scoops will help you shorten your prep time, eliminate your food waste and let you have an even baking time.
Also, cookie scoops help you with consistent cookie sizes and they are very simple to use. However, if you’re still not convinced and want to do it the hard way, you can use an ice-cream scoop or even a tablespoon if you want to.
Although most ice-cream scoops don’t have a spring mechanism.
How much dough can I scoop?
Cookie scoops that have a size less than #10, can even hold more as much as 10 tablespoons of dough. Anyway, most scoops are medium-sized and they usually hold three or four tablespoons. Small sizes like #70 or #100 size, hold even less than a tablespoon.
So, there is a wide number of possibilities for you!
What else I can do with a cookie scoop?
Cookie scoops come in handy for loads of measurements in the kitchen. You can use them with muffin batter, cupcake batter, cake batter, falafels, meatballs, gravy, mashed potatoes, and so many other things.
Learn about other usages of cookie scoops.
Are cookie scoops worth the money?
If you love baking cookies, then, of course, they are worth the money. Most cookie scoops are very affordable and you can find a working one for less than twenty dollars! So, yes they are worth the money.
Cookies bring happiness to you and all the people around you with their sweetness. So, baking cookies for fun should be an actual fun activity, shouldn’t it?
But, to make this tough job “fun”, you need the best cookie scoop. A good scoop along with your recipe could just result in the perfect cookies anyone ever had! So, have fun with your cookies.